The student can in a basic way participate in the seminar by being somewhat active, but also by at times listening and responding to what's said by others. Knowledge is demonstrated in a basic way, but statements are sometimes vague, unclear, and lacks concrete examples

The student can in a very good way participate in the seminar by being rather active, but also by often listening and responding to what's said by others. Knowledge is demonstrated in a mostly clear way, with some concrete examples

The student participates in a great way in the seminar by being very active, but also by listening and responding to what's said by others. Knowledge is demonstrated in a clear and developed way, with concrete examples.

The student analysis one or two of the issues discussed in a basic way, but without developing the analysis, and with few detailes, and little connection to other issues

The student analysis a few of the issues discussed in a detailed way, and at times developes the analysis, and adds details, and some connection to other issues

The student analysis a most of the issues discussed in a detailed and developed way, by provding details and clear links to other issues